I love eyeliners. I have a whole container just for them . Mostly colored ones. Not only because I love the colors, but they smudge less. Finding a smudge or fade free liner is always top of the list. There are some good ones but the best so far I have bought is Sephora's Flashy Waterproof.
It truly lasts all day. My eyeshadow may wear off , but that liner is still there. I have it in Flashy Brown which is really a very deep copper unlike the Copper one which is more gold. I love the color, and the soft texture. Better yet, it's only $ 8.00.
The Flashy liner comes in pink, silver, mauve,orange, teal, turquoise as well as black.
I just made my friends and family order. Now I wish I added some of these to it. I have the best color though. That's good for now.